Managing a Dishonest Employee Who Won't Work: What to Do

Few management challenges are as draining as supervising an employee who combines chronic dishonesty with persistent underperformance. When a direct report routinely misrepresents her progress, deflects accountability, and leaves work undone, a manager faces not just a performance problem but a trust deficit that can corrode an entire team's morale and cohesion.

The instinct to protect one's own reputation — captured in the blunt desire to keep one's name out of a problematic employee's mouth — is understandable, but workplace experts generally caution that reactive or emotionally driven responses can backfire. Documentation, consistency, and a clear escalation path through HR are the tools that ultimately protect a manager legally and professionally.

Read more Excelsior Energy Sells Two Solar Plants to Enel for $760M →

From an organizational behavior standpoint, pathological lying in the workplace is distinct from ordinary excuse-making. It tends to be habitual, resistant to confrontation, and often accompanied by blame-shifting. Managers who address only the performance symptoms without acknowledging the underlying pattern of deception may find themselves in repeated cycles of false improvement and relapse.

The structural advice in situations like this is straightforward even if the execution is difficult: set measurable, time-bound expectations in writing, document every deviation, and loop in human resources early rather than late. Attempting to manage the situation informally or through social pressure alone rarely produces lasting change and can expose the manager to claims of unfair treatment if the relationship deteriorates further.

Ultimately, the goal is not to "win" a power struggle with a difficult report but to create a paper trail that reflects good-faith efforts to support improvement — and that supports a personnel action if improvement never comes. Continue reading at MarketWatch.com